Last updated: 22 Oct 2026 · 9 min read
By Pulkit Mangal — F&O trader since 2017, founder of TradeDiary. Past trading experience across Zerodha, Kotak and Dhan; built TradeDiary after losing ₹14L in 2021 to mistakes a journal would have caught.
TL;DR: A commodity trading journal tracks every MCX fill — crude oil, gold, silver, natural gas — with the lot multiplier, session hours and charges that make commodity P&L different from equity F&O. Most equity journals either skip MCX rows or get the lot size wrong. If your journal says you made ₹12,000 on crude but your ledger says ₹1,200, the multiplier is the gap.
You sold 1 lot of CRUDEOILM at ₹8,600 and bought it back at ₹8,550. Profit: ₹50 per barrel × 10 barrels = ₹500. Your spreadsheet, which works fine for NIFTY options, recorded ₹50 — because it has no idea that CRUDEOILM trades in barrels. You found out a week later, when your monthly P&L was off by a factor of 10 on every crude trade and you could not tell which number to trust.
That is the core problem a commodity trading journal solves. Not "journaling" in the motivational sense. Plumbing: the right multiplier, the right session hours, the right charges, in a format that reconciles against the broker's ledger without mental arithmetic.
💡 Short on time? Try the free F&O journal — import your broker statement and it handles MCX lot sizes, session hours and charge breakdowns automatically.
What "commodity trading journal" actually means
A commodity trading journal is a structured record of every trade on the Multi Commodity Exchange (MCX) — and potentially NCDEX, though almost all retail volume is MCX — that captures the fields needed to compute P&L correctly and learn from the trades afterward.
For Indian traders, three things make commodity journaling different from equity or index F&O:
-
Lot sizes are physical units, not shares. CRUDEOIL is 100 barrels. CRUDEOILM (the mini) is 10 barrels. GOLD is 100 grams, GOLDM is 10 grams, GOLDGUINEA is 1 gram. SILVER is 30 kilograms, SILVERM is 5 kg. These multipliers turn a ₹50 price move into ₹5,000, ₹500 or ₹50 depending on which contract you traded. An equity journal that treats quantity as "number of lots" gets every P&L cell wrong.
-
Market hours are different — and they split. MCX trades from 9:00 AM to 11:30 PM (11:55 PM during US daylight saving). On certain days — exchange holidays, special sessions — the morning session (9:00–5:00 PM) can be off while the evening session (5:00–11:30 PM) runs normally, or vice versa. A journal that checks "is it after 3:30 PM?" and stops refreshing will miss six hours of price action.
-
Charges follow a different rate card. MCX has no Securities Transaction Tax (STT) — it has Commodity Transaction Tax (CTT), which applies only to sell-side transactions and only to non-agricultural commodities. The exchange fee, SEBI fee and stamp duty rates differ from NSE/BSE. A journal that applies the NSE charge formula to a crude trade overstates charges on buys (no CTT on buy) and understates the exchange fee.
Why it matters for Indian commodity traders
Your lot multiplier is buried in the contract spec
When you import a Zerodha tradebook or a Kotak order book into a spreadsheet, the quantity column says "10" for a CRUDEOILM trade. Is that 10 lots or 10 barrels? It is 10 barrels — 1 lot. But the same column for a NIFTY option saying "50" means 1 lot of 50 units. The meaning of the quantity field changes by exchange, and no header tells you which convention you are looking at.
CTT, not STT — and the rate is different
Since 1 April 2026, STT on equity options (sell side) is 0.15% of premium. CTT on non-agricultural commodity options (sell side) is 0.05% of premium. That is a third of the equity rate. If your journal uses the STT rate for crude options, every charge estimate is 3× too high, and your net P&L is understated by the difference. (Zerodha charges page breaks this down by segment.)
The evening session is where crude moves
Crude oil and natural gas track global benchmarks. US inventory data (EIA, every Wednesday at 8:00 PM IST) and OPEC announcements land during the MCX evening session. A journal that only captures the "market hours" window of 9:15–3:30 misses the session where the largest commodity moves happen — and where most retail crude P&L is made or lost.
SEBI's 9-out-of-10 finding applies here too
SEBI's January 2024 study found that 9 out of 10 individual traders in the equity F&O segment lost money, with average losses of ₹50,000 over FY22. MCX was not in that study's scope, but the structural dynamics — high leverage, weekly expiries, retail-vs-institutional asymmetry — are the same. A trading journal is the minimum infrastructure for knowing whether you are in the 10% or the 90%. (SEBI study, 25-Jan-2024)
What a commodity trading journal should track
Whatever tool you use, these fields turn a trade log into something you can reconcile and analyse:
| Field | Why it matters for MCX |
|---|---|
| Underlying + contract variant | CRUDEOIL vs CRUDEOILM vs CRUDEOILM (mini) — the lot size changes by 10× |
| Exchange | MCX, not NSE/BSE — determines charge rates, session hours, settlement rules |
| Lot size (units) | 100 BBL, 10 BBL, 100 g, 30 kg — the multiplier that turns price into rupees |
| Entry and exit price | Per-unit price (per barrel, per gram), not the total value |
| Quantity in units | Barrels, grams, kilograms — as the broker reports it |
| Session | Morning, evening, or both — tags when the trade happened in the MCX window |
| Charges per trade | CTT (sell only, non-agri), exchange fee, SEBI fee, stamp duty (buy only), GST, brokerage |
| Expiry date | Monthly or weekly; commodity expiries can fall on dates equity traders don't expect |
Optional but useful: the global benchmark the commodity tracks (Brent, COMEX gold, Henry Hub), the time of entry (for correlation with news — EIA, OPEC, Fed), and margin utilised (commodity margins are volatile and can change intraday).
How to journal MCX trades, step by step
1. Fix the multiplier before anything else
Open your broker's contract note or tradebook. Find one MCX trade. Check: does the "quantity" column show units (barrels, grams) or lots? For Zerodha and Kotak, it is units. Verify by multiplying quantity × price and comparing with the "trade value" or "amount" column. If it matches, quantity is in units and your journal's P&L formula is (exit_price − entry_price) × quantity. If it does not match, the broker is reporting lots, and you need to multiply by the contract's lot size.
2. Separate MCX charges from equity charges
Do not apply the same charge formula to all segments. For a non-agricultural MCX trade: - CTT: 0.05% of sell-side premium (options) or 0.01% of sell-side value (futures) — only on sells - Exchange fee: 0.0026% (futures) or 0.05% (options) — both sides - SEBI fee: ₹10 per crore — both sides - Stamp duty: state-specific, buy side only - GST: 18% on exchange fee + SEBI fee (not on CTT) - Brokerage: per your plan (Zerodha: ₹20 per executed order or 0.03%, whichever is lower)
Agricultural commodities (cotton, mentha oil, castor seed, CPO) pay no CTT. Check before applying.
3. Record the session, not just the date
A crude trade at 10:30 AM and one at 9:45 PM are on the same calendar date but in different market sessions with different liquidity profiles. Tag the session (morning/evening) or at least record the timestamp. When you review losing trades later, you will often find they cluster in one session — usually the one where you had less focus.
4. Reconcile against the broker's ledger weekly
Pull your broker's MCX segment P&L or ledger at the end of each week. Compare your journal's total P&L for the week against the broker's number. If they differ, the gap is almost always one of: a wrong lot multiplier, a missed fill (partial fill reported as complete), a charge mismatch, or an expired option not settled. Fix the gap while the trades are fresh — it becomes archaeology after a month.
5. Tag by underlying, not by contract
CRUDEOIL and CRUDEOILM are the same underlying — crude oil on MCX. Your analysis should group them together: "How am I doing on crude?" not "How am I doing on this specific contract?" The lot size differs, but the edge (or lack of it) is the same trade.
A real example with numbers
Ravi, 34, a chartered accountant in Ahmedabad, trades crude oil options in the MCX evening session with ₹3L of capital. His September 2026 journal:
| Strategy | Trades | Win rate | Gross P&L | CTT + charges | Net P&L |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Directional (CRUDEOILM puts around EIA) | 14 | 57% | +₹18,400 | −₹1,840 | +₹16,560 |
| Straddle sells (non-event days) | 8 | 75% | +₹9,200 | −₹1,380 | +₹7,820 |
| Revenge trades after a loss (unplanned) | 4 | 0% | −₹14,600 | −₹730 | −₹15,330 |
| Total | 26 | 54% | +₹13,000 | −₹3,950 | +₹9,050 |
Two findings surfaced only because the journal was honest. First, Ravi's net after charges was ₹9,050 on ₹3L capital — 3% for the month, not the ₹13,000 gross he saw on his broker's screen. Second, the four revenge trades (tagged "tilt" — he uses a one-word emotion tag per trade) wiped out 62% of his winning P&L. Without the tag, those four trades were invisible inside the aggregate numbers. With it, the fix was obvious: a hard rule to stop trading for the night after two consecutive losses. October's revenge-trade count dropped to one. (Why revenge trades matter explains the psychology.)
Common mistakes
- Using the equity lot size for MCX — NIFTY lot = 75 units, CRUDEOILM lot = 10 barrels. If your journal says "lot size" without specifying the contract, it will be wrong for one of them.
- Applying STT instead of CTT — STT does not exist on MCX. CTT is lower and applies only to sells. Overestimating charges hides your real edge.
- Ignoring the evening session — crude and gold make their biggest moves after 8 PM IST. A journal that stops at 3:30 PM is missing the data you need most.
- Treating CRUDEOIL and CRUDEOILM as unrelated — they are the same underlying with different lot sizes. Analyse them together to see your actual crude performance.
- Not settling expired options — a commodity option that expires worthless must be recorded at zero, not left "open" in your journal. An unsettled position inflates your running P&L.
- Rounding charges to "about 2%" — commodity charges vary by product, side and type. A flat percentage is wrong for every trade; the error compounds over a month.
How TradeDiary helps
TradeDiary imports broker statements from Zerodha, Kotak, Dhan, Angel One and Upstox, and handles MCX lot sizes (CRUDEOIL at 100 BBL, CRUDEOILM at 10 BBL, GOLD at 100 g, and 25+ other commodities) so your P&L is in rupees, not mystery units. The brokerage calculator breaks down CTT, exchange fees and stamp duty by segment — MCX futures, MCX options, or agricultural — so you can verify every charge line. For traders on the Verified P&L pilot (Kotak Neo), MCX positions are captured alongside NFO and BFO, valued at the broker's close, with charges estimated from the exchange rate card.
Start your free commodity trading journal →
You may also like: Options trading journal India · F&O tax journal · Trade journal vs spreadsheet · Trading edge explained
Frequently asked questions
What is a commodity trading journal? A commodity trading journal is a structured record of every trade on MCX (or NCDEX), including the contract, lot size in physical units, entry and exit prices, charges (CTT, exchange fee, stamp duty) and the session it was traded in. It differs from an equity journal because lot sizes are in barrels, grams or kilograms, charges follow the MCX rate card (CTT instead of STT), and market hours extend to 11:30 PM.
Does a commodity trading journal need different fields from an equity journal? Yes. The critical additions are the lot multiplier (100 barrels for CRUDEOIL, 10 for CRUDEOILM), the session tag (morning or evening), and the commodity-specific charge breakdown (CTT on sells only, no STT, different exchange fee rates). Without these, P&L and charge figures will be wrong.
What is the difference between CTT and STT? STT (Securities Transaction Tax) applies to equity and index F&O on NSE and BSE. CTT (Commodity Transaction Tax) applies to non-agricultural commodity derivatives on MCX. CTT on options is 0.05% of sell-side premium — roughly a third of the current STT rate on equity options (0.15%). Agricultural commodities are exempt from CTT entirely.
Can I use the same journal for MCX and NSE F&O? Yes, as long as the journal handles different lot-size conventions and charge formulas per exchange. A journal that applies one formula to all segments will get P&L wrong for at least one of them. TradeDiary and similar tools handle this automatically; a spreadsheet needs separate charge columns for each segment.
What MCX commodities can I journal in TradeDiary? TradeDiary supports all actively traded MCX commodities — crude oil (CRUDEOIL, CRUDEOILM), gold (GOLD, GOLDM, GOLDGUINEA, GOLDPETAL), silver (SILVER, SILVERM, SILVERMIC), natural gas (NATURALGAS, NATGASMINI), copper, zinc, lead, aluminium, nickel, cotton, mentha oil and others. Lot sizes are built in; the brokerage calculator covers MCX-specific charges.
Risk disclaimer
Trading in commodity derivatives carries substantial risk. SEBI's January 2024 study found that 9 out of 10 individual traders in the equity F&O segment lost money, with average losses of ₹50,000 over FY22. Commodity F&O carries similar structural risks. (SEBI study, 25-Jan-2024)
TradeDiary is not a SEBI-registered investment adviser or research analyst. This article is general information about commodity trade journaling, not investment or tax advice.
Pulkit Mangal trades F&O on Indian markets and builds TradeDiary, a trading journal made for the Indian F&O trader.
Last updated: 22 Oct 2026.